You cannot develop a full, rich, robust communityif your paramount concern is to programmatically thwart bad actors.If you don't believe that the trust and good will engenderedamong a manageable number of comradeswho collectively undertake communal interactions and collective actionsis enough to prevent the triumph of bad actorsthen you have deemed the project of community doomed at the outset.

@baslow I’ve seen various attempted social movements claiming that "we’re worth more than this" and failing on the long run, or getting enclaved on the border of the campus (in their presidence-assigned buildings), because they would fail to positively describe the world we'd want to live in. The cultural/advocacy part for any marginalized community is very important; pride comes among the most salient aspects of such a culture, and the French private television, although required when I was a teenager for my overworked mum’s mental health (resting mentally for half an hour), has made me ashamed of coming from the lower class, sort of deserving poor treatments like low grades, which are by the way an education disaster, but also kinda useful to keep a strong social hierarchy across generations. If people feel too ashamed to even claim a decent way of life, and this might be especially true for our declining middle class, then they will merely see the world in terms of what they oppose to, what they need, and not in terms of imagining a better society that would be worth spending nights figuring out what it could be and how to get there.
@baslow Talking about this students social movement getting enclaved in their presidence-assigned buildings (harshly negociated, in their young naive minds) on the border of the campus, which were dedicated to the less funded, legitimate cursus they offered, they've stayed in these buildings for 2 years. Then they went in a brand new building rented by Vinci, dedicated among other things to sociology ("we aren't defunding sociology, look, we're renting a building for them"), rang the fire alarm, and we occupied the building, put tables in a circle, and on this horizontal model started to discuss about our individual end-of-the-semester reports.


We all wanted this social movement to succeed and I've never experienced something similar, and it lasted for about 2 hours before the police came and evacuated the building (which means the presidence had approved the police intervention), before blocking access to the building until the end of the year.

There's a lot to unpack here, so I'm spending some time thinking about it before I respond...

Load 1 more replies