Chris Wood
activity timestamp 3 years ago
@ivan I just tried out leaving a comment on a public prototype.


If you're not logged in, you have the option of leaving a comment, but it doesn't work. Pressing "Send" in the comment box results in a message that says "There was an error." There was no mention of what the problem was, but I'm guessing it's because I wasn't not logged in.


If you are logged in, you can comment without a problem.


There are a lot of teething issues with Penpot at the moment and I found it slower to work in than Figma. I've been keeping an eye on the project and I provide feedback to the team, and I hope it continues to improve. But right now, I wouldn't recommend it for use in production unless you're willing to make some time to log the bugs and problems you encounter along the way.
ivan
activity timestamp 3 years ago

did a first attempt: here a (almost) pixel perfect myfeed page: design.penpot.app/#/view/a90... I've created components out of all the main widgets / sections - it was fun, it's true, it is slower than figma but already quite usable imo
ivan
activity timestamp 3 years ago
@Azuredusk10 wow this is so great, thanks for putting so much thoughts on it 😍 😍

This is quite a sincronicity indeed, because we are having this discussion again with @mayel since the past week.

It makes me wonder 2 things:

  • Your initiative is an opportunity to try to develop such crucial feature (both in terms of user adoption and in term of economic sustainability) in the open and together with the community
  • We can move the actual bonfire mockups design system from figma to penpot, and try to make it more accessible for other designers to use / improve it
Dazinism
activity timestamp 3 years ago
@Azuredusk10 @bonfire @fediverse @ivan

Having worked on a lot of projects with low/no budget, particularly at their beginning, I wonder if a good 'solidarity' support structure could be designed?

Im thinking free to get going, with some explanation of resources required to keep it going and requests for contributions.


Maybe some easy way for the hoster to have good visibility into resource usage and to trigger requests - that could optionally go out to the instance 'admin' and/or their users (give the admin some choices)

Also have some clearly defined streams for regular contributions where you may then avoid requests
Chris Wood
activity timestamp 3 years ago
@ivan Thank you for taking a look!


I imagine that lots of Fediverse projects require some technical knowledge to set up. Even something relatively straightforward like "Go to Mastohost's website and pay for a hosting plan" might seem easy to someone with experience, but overwhelming for someone who doesn't know what they're doing.


It would be brilliant to work on removing that technical skills barrier in the open and create a new source of revenue for the projects. That's a great idea 🙌 if there's anything more I can help with, I'd love to be involved.


There might be concerns around having only 1 private company hosting the majority of instances for a platform, e.g. what happens if the platform gets very popular and an investor buys the biggest hosting company of that platform? It would be worth thinking about how we tackle that as well.


In terms of moving the design system to Penpot, I should let you know that you can share a prototype publicy like I did, but you can't share the actual design file publicy. You can only invite others to join via email - there's no option to share a view-only link or anything like that, which you have in Figma. So I think it would be harder for other designers to access Bonfire's design work if you move it into Penpot at this time.